Added Sugar vs. Natural Sugar: What Is the Difference?
Sugar is on almost every food label, and it gets confusing fast. A cup of plain yogurt and a can of soda can both show a lot of sugar on the label. Are those the same thing?
Not exactly, and the label can help you see the difference. Here is how to read it.
What counts as added sugar
The FDA defines added sugars as sugars that are added during the processing of foods, plus foods packaged as sugars, such as table sugar. The list includes:
- Table sugar and other sugars used in cooking or baking
- Syrups and honey
- Sugars from concentrated fruit or vegetable juices
It does not include the sugars that occur naturally in milk, fruits and vegetables.
That is why honey, maple syrup and agave count as added sugars even though they feel natural. When they are poured on your oatmeal or stirred into your tea, they are added.
Why the two are treated differently
The sugar molecules themselves are chemically similar. The difference is what comes with them.
A piece of whole fruit packs its sugar into fiber, water and other nutrients, which makes it slower and harder to overeat. A soda delivers sugar and little else. The Dietary Guidelines for Americans make the same point about juice: 100 percent fruit juice with no added sugar can be part of a healthy diet, but it is lower in fiber than whole fruit, and fruit should mostly be eaten in whole form.
The guidelines also warn about products that look like juice but are not. Many "fruit drinks" contain very little juice and are mostly water and added sugar, so they count as sugar-sweetened beverages.
How much is too much
There is more than one number out there, so here they are side by side:
| Source | Limit for added sugars |
|---|---|
| Dietary Guidelines for Americans | Less than 10% of daily calories (about 50 g on a 2,000 calorie diet) |
| American Heart Association, women | No more than 100 calories a day (about 25 g, or 6 teaspoons) |
| American Heart Association, men | No more than 150 calories a day (about 37.5 g, or 9 teaspoons) |
| Average American intake | About 270 calories a day, more than 13% of total calories |
The gram and teaspoon conversions for the AHA limits use a simple rule of 4 calories and about 4 grams per teaspoon of sugar. The AHA statement itself gives the limits in calories.
The two limits are not in conflict. The Dietary Guidelines set the outer boundary, and the American Heart Association suggests a more cautious target. Most people are above both.
Where most added sugar comes from
It is not mostly from the sugar bowl. According to the Dietary Guidelines, the major sources of added sugars in the typical American diet are:
- Sugar-sweetened beverages, such as soda and fruit drinks
- Desserts and sweet snacks
- Sweetened coffee and tea
- Candy
Together, these four make up more than half of all the added sugar Americans eat, and they contribute very little to the food groups we are told to eat more of.
How to find it on the label
The Nutrition Facts label has an Added Sugars line, listed right under Total Sugars. It tells you the grams and the percent Daily Value, which is based on 50 grams a day.
For example (these are illustrative numbers), a plain yogurt might show 12 grams of total sugar and 0 grams of added sugar, while a flavored yogurt might show 20 grams of total sugar and 12 grams of added sugar. The first is mostly natural milk sugar. The second has a lot of sweetener on top. Our guide to reading a Nutrition Facts label shows how to use the 5 and 20 percent rule to spot a lot or a little.
The ingredient list helps too. Sugars show up under many names, so words like syrup, honey, cane sugar and fruit juice concentrate are worth noticing.
Five simple ways to cut added sugar
The Dietary Guidelines suggest reducing portions, eating the high sugar foods less often and choosing versions with less added sugar. Here is how that looks in practice:
- Start with what you drink. Drinks are the biggest source, and it is the easiest swap. Water, sparkling water or unsweetened tea go a long way.
- Step down the sweetener. If you sweeten coffee or tea, try a bit less each week.
- Add the sweet yourself. Plain yogurt or oatmeal with fruit gives sweetness with fiber and no added sugar.
- Check the usual suspects. Cereals, granola, flavored yogurt, sauces and bread often carry more added sugar than you would guess.
- Make desserts an occasion. Smaller portions, less often, are easier to keep up than banning them.
Added sugar is also common in ultra-processed foods, so cutting back on one often helps with the other.
The takeaways
- Natural sugars are in foods like fruit and milk. Added sugars are put in during processing or cooking.
- Honey, syrups and fruit juice concentrates all count as added sugars.
- The Dietary Guidelines say under 10 percent of calories. The AHA suggests 100 calories for women and 150 for men.
- Most added sugar comes from drinks, sweets, desserts and sweetened coffee or tea.
- Look at the Added Sugars line on the label, not only Total Sugars.
Added sugar questions people ask
What is the difference between added sugar and natural sugar?
Is the sugar in fruit bad for you?
Is honey an added sugar?
How many grams of added sugar should you eat per day?
How much added sugar does the average American eat?
Sources
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Added Sugars on the Nutrition Facts Label.
- U.S. Department of Agriculture and U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2020-2025. Added sugars intake and sources (Chapter 1), juice (Chapter 3).
- Johnson RK, Appel LJ, Brands M, et al. Dietary sugars intake and cardiovascular health: a scientific statement from the American Heart Association. Circulation. 2009;120(11):1011-1020.
Get new guides by email
Plain-English food and health research, with the sources linked. No hype, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
By subscribing you agree to receive emails from Healthy Years Report. See our privacy policy.
This guide is for general education. It is not medical advice and is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Talk to your doctor or a registered dietitian before changing your diet, especially if you take medication or manage a health condition.